Comparison of Natural and Intensive Systems



The natural system is complex, with a wide variety of species, energy pathways, and nutrient translocation pathways. Coarse woody debris provides a critical reservoir of moisture and nutrients, and in many systems has been described as the site of nitrogen fixation by cyanobacteria. Actinomycetes in the nodules on the roots of species like red alder (Alnus rubra hosting Frankia) also "fix" nitrogen, converting gaseous atmospheric nitrogen into a nitrate form useable by plants. A diverse array of organisms, ranging from anadromous fish in the stream to insects and birds in the air contribute to a healthy flow of energy in the system.
Simplicity is the key word when it comes to describing the hybrid poplar stand. Anthropogenic selection focuses as much of the available soil resources (nutrients and water) on a single species (in this case a highly productive hybrid) as possible. Doing this can produce high biomass yields. However, a monoculture is ecologically less stable than a diverse, natural system, subject to pest outbreaks, disease, and degradation of the soil. In this system, nutrient replacement processes are inhibited, discouraged, or eliminated.


Return to Hybrid Poplar Intro